State Income Tax Overhauls: The Flat Tax Movement Gains Momentum

Across the United States, several states are contemplating a major shift towards flat income tax systems, aiming to streamline their tax codes and stimulate economic growth. These systems impose a uniform tax rate on all taxpayers, regardless of income. Proponents argue that such reforms foster simplicity and competitiveness, while critics highlight potential adverse effects on state revenue and income equality.  Image 2

South Carolina has entered the spotlight with its ambitious flat tax proposal, marking a new chapter in state tax reform discussions.

South Carolina’s Ambitious 3.99% Flat Tax Proposal

South Carolina is poised to undertake a significant reform of its tax structure. In April 2025, South Carolina legislators moved forward with a plan to revise the existing top marginal rate from 6.4% to a flat 3.99% by 2027. House Speaker Murrell Smith shared with the Associated Press, “We’re aiming to convey a clear message that South Carolina is welcoming to business.” The proposed bill offers a provision to further decrease the rate to 2.49% if future revenue projections exceed expectations.

Advocates in South Carolina believe this move will enhance competitiveness with low-tax neighbors like Florida and Tennessee, both having no state income tax. Conversely, critics warn that potential revenue losses could impact public services and education.

An Expanding Trend Across Red and Purple States

Other states are considering similar fiscal strategies. In Missouri, new legislation exempts capital gains from state income tax, a measure likely to impact revenue significantly. Meanwhile, in Montana, Governor Greg Gianforte endorsed House Bill 337, reducing the top income tax rate to 5.65% in 2026 and 5.4% by 2027, while broadening lower tax bracket eligibility and doubling the earned income tax credit.

Image 1 Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt and legislative leaders revealed a budget plan that reduces state income tax by 0.25% and consolidates income tax brackets, paving a pathway towards tax elimination.

In Alabama, discussions are underway about tax reform, including the reduction of the state grocery tax from 4% to 3% in 2023. Further measures, including a flat rate, remain under consideration. States like Indiana, already enacting a flat tax, plan to adjust their rate from 3.15% to 2.9% by 2027, contemplating an acceleration or permanence of these cuts.

Even Kansas, despite previous financial challenges post-Governor Sam Brownback’s extensive tax cuts, has rejoined the flat tax discourse. Although Governor Laura Kelly vetoed a flat tax proposal in 2024, revised versions are anticipated for the 2026 legislative session.

Critics Question: “A Tax Break for the Affluent?”

Advocates of flat taxes highlight benefits such as clarity, transparency, and heightened economic appeal, yet detractors assert that these advantages predominantly favor wealthier individuals.

“While flat taxes may appear equitable on paper, they inadvertently shift the financial burden,” noted Carl Davis, research director at the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), in a recent State Rundown. An analysis by ITEP reveals the bottom 20% often bear a proportionately larger tax burden compared to the top 1% in many flat tax regions.

This contention resonates in several states. In South Carolina, opponents caution that implementing a 3.99% flat tax could extract nearly $1 billion from the state’s budget over five years, necessitating potential cuts to education, infrastructure, or Medicaid.

Uniform Doesn’t Imply Egalitarian or Final

Despite mounting popularity, flat tax reforms entail complexities. Most states remain dependent on federal aid and sales taxes. Without comprehensive safety nets, poorly conceived flat taxes might disproportionately affect low-income households.

Politicians like Colorado’s Governor Jared Polis have shown interest in tax code simplification. Polis emphasized responsible execution, remarking in a 2020 statement via the Colorado Tax Policy Center, “A broader base taxed at a lower rate can enhance growth while deterring crony capitalism.”

His stance represents a growing trend among policymakers favoring tax reforms that promote economic efficiency while ensuring sustainable fiscal health.

As the legislative season of 2025 approaches, more states are expected to delve into the flat tax debate. Success will likely hinge on the balance between revenue adequacy and fairness promises.

One certainty emerges: the flat tax era has transitioned from abstract to in-motion, gathering notable traction.

Share this article...

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.

Haley Claypool Tax Firm Ask Us a Question
Welcome to TaxBot - Your smart tax assistant, simplifying deductions and maximizing returns.
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully